|
Hot
off the CD-burners is a new range of products called WiseImage V
from Consistent Software. This range of products is a step-up from
the previous versions called Spotlight and AutoImage. But, wait a
minute, weren’t these products sold worldwide by another company?
A little investigation clarifies the situation. Although these
products used to be marketed under their old names until last year
by a "now" competitor of Consistent Software, the truth is
that they have always been developed by Consistent Software. Also,
with the introduction of the latest product with its new improved
features and functionality, and a completely re-written source code
from top to bottom, the natural progression was to introduce a new
name. - WiseImage. With a name like WiseImage you need to show
something exceptional, and as they say "the proof is in the
pudding".
Platform compatibility.
Although
we only tested the WiseImage Pro for Windows and its AutoCAD 2002
equivalent, WiseImage is the only product that offers a complete
cross-platform functionality spread on AutoCAD, AutoCAD LT, AutoCAD
Map, and Architectural Desktop, and as a stand-alone version for
Windows. Competitors like Autodesk and GTX only offer full raster
enabling in AutoCAD, not LT and others like Softelec cannot offer a
full range of product functionality to all the platforms.
Add to this the fact that Consistent Software sell WiseImage V for
AutoCAD as a triple license, which enables users to choose their
platform of preference from the purchase of one product. A user may
even install all three versions, and run them one at a time.
WiseImage offers the same functionality on all platforms, but the
interaction is slightly different when you use the Windows version
as opposed to the AutoCAD versions. In the Windows version WiseImage
is in charge of its own vectors. It is not a CAD system, but it
offers a lot of native CAD entities, actually more than any of the
competitors. When it comes to the AutoCAD environment, WiseImage
abides by all the Autodesk rules. This allows the user to call and
manipulate all functions from the
command prompt, just like native AutoCAD commands.
Raster is objects
How WiseImage recognizes the different objects is not wizardry. What
seems to be magic, however, is the way that WiseImage enables raster
to become so much like vector that it defies logic. WiseImage allows
you to select entities intelligently like lines, circles and arcs.
These entities come with knowledge on entity type, marker start and
end, entity width, entity start, middle and end point, delta length,
center, bulge, radius, start and end angle, sector and more, just
like any normal vector. The selection of raster is done using the
widest array of selection tools of any product in the market. You
can even select and manipulate blocks of recognized entities in one
go. Again this is done just like you would with a CAD system. You
can group, ungroup, move, copy, snap, rotate, mirror, flip, array
and other standard vector manipulations.
The
software even allows you to manipulate raster objects relative to
existing vector objects and vice versa. The example shows a raster
rectangle duplicated four times as an Array onto a vector line.
OCR and Symbol recognition
Included
with the pro version of all products are an OCR engine, and a tool
for symbol recognition. For any serious work these tools are very
handy. Also as you will see discussed further down in this article
the symbol recognition allows users from all different vertical
markets to make predefined or even use imported symbol templates for
very fast and accurate recognition.
OCR
Consistent
Software has developed the OCR engine in-house. This engine is
specifically designed for recognition of drawing text and not
document text. Thus the focus of WiseImage is to allow you to train
the OCR for pattern recognition rather than bundling a dictionary
for pattern recognitions. Mastering set up of OCR patterns is
simple. The different available definitions are, D for digits
(numbers) and E or e for English alphabet upper and lower case
letters. For National alphabets like Cyrillic, Greek or
Scandinavian, and more, the character N or n defines upper and lower
case. Finally the letter K allows you to input Keyword patterns that
will not be part of the recognition. You can also use any specific
character to define a template. Add to this the fact that you can
also specify the number of digits or characters in a template, or
any variation of these, and you will recognize that you have an
extremely customizable and powerful template builder available in
this solution.
As
seen in this template example, there are three different template
types.
1.
%E = Any number of Uppercase English alphabet characters
2. %D = Any number of digits
3. %KNO. = Keyword (label) with exact pattern matching
"NO."
You
could also define a template with %D%E = any number of digits before
any number of capital letters, or %D%e1 = any number of digits plus
one lower case letter.
Although
the WiseImage built in OCR module was capable of an almost perfect
result by accurately specifying templates, the result was totally
acceptable when we did nothing to specify the templates.
"Remember that no matter what percentage a SW supplier offers
you as accuracy of recognition of text, the fact remains that there
is no tool available that can tell you what 10% or 0.001% is in
error. During the OCR tests we also used the external OCR engine,
FineReader. Although the FineReader engine was superior on large
quantities of text, the built in OCR seemed to be easier to adapt to
the job at hand. The big difference being that FineReader uses a
library of words to compare against when recognizing text, and the
WiseImage default OCR uses its own built in templates to recognize
the text. Obviously there is normally more jitter and jazz on the
title-block of a drawing than normal words and phrases. As any added
OCR will increase the cost of the system, it seems to us that the SW
offers ample OCR support as it is delivered.
Symbol recognition
Many raster solutions in the market today are capable of recognizing
symbols. What sets WiseImage apart from its competitors is that this
ability is expanded to enable very complex patterns of recognition.
Even though the symbol might be complex, the capability of WiseImage
allows you to set a parameter for the accuracy of the recognition.
By reducing the accuracy of the recognition, symbols of varying size
and alignment were added to the recognition as long as they confided
with the exact pattern specified.
Using
this kind of tool on architectural drawings of buildings, for
example, will allow you to replace old hand drawn windows on a
building façade with new windows from a pre-defined template. This
template may be imported from AutoCAD standard libraries.
The symbol recognition is absolutely the most powerful tool we have
ever seen. For anyone working with floor plans, old house drawings,
schematics, process drawings or other drawings where symbols are
repetitive, this tool will speed up conversion or
recognition. Architects, plant managers, facilitators and more could
easily justify the investment of owning WiseImage.
More functionality
WiseImage is a very complex product. There seems to be almost no
limit to its capabilities when it comes to raster editing. This is
probably the worst feature of the product; it may be too advanced.
However, any user of AutoCAD will have no problems becoming
productive with this product. They will feel right at home with all
the functionality and probably forget that they are using a third
party product in AutoCAD when they are manipulating raster or hybrid
data.
Users
of WiseImage for Windows will have to learn all the capabilities of
the SW from scratch. The user interface, and the logic of
functionality are complex, but intuitive. It even enables a user to
build personal toolbars, and menus to speed up or streamline usage
of the product.
Repro
houses and copy shops dealing with large quantities of drawings will
benefit from the built in batch generator that enables predefined
series of actions to be performed on sets of drawings without
operator assistance. You can select to have WiseImage do automatic
alignment, filtering (despeckle, hole filling, thinning and many
more), crop to frame, fit to paper size and other functions. You can
even do batch OCR and symbol recognition.
Raster
to vector conversion allows the user to define layer by width and
type. WiseImage even has a WYSIWYG pre-process viewer allowing the
user to interactively verify the intended process. R2V is not the
fastest around, but the quality is very good. We have seen faster
conversions done on comparable drawings in other products, but the
result is often so that time saved in the automatic conversion is
more than lost in the preprocessing cleanup of the vectors in the
end. What you need when you convert is useful information. If your
result is a bunch of stupid vectors, you are better off with just a
stupid raster image. The best is however to have an intelligent
hybrid image, and this is exactly what WiseImage offers, intelligent
raster and hybrid imaging.
There
are too many functions to cover in detail in a short article like
this one, so here is a list of some of the functions that are not
covered. Color filtering and layering. Color conversion and line
tracing. Multipage TIFF creation and management. VB-Script enabled,
OCX module available, OLE compliant and tons of other useful tools.
The
only way you, as a potential user, can verify if this product will
help your production needs, is to request a demo, or download a
fully working demo copy for your own personal trials. If you do, and
are not an AutoCAD user, you will save time if you read parts of the
user manual before you start. This will familiarize you with the
product and how it functions.
Summary
As
the author has previous knowledge of both the WiseImage predecessors
AutoImage and Spotlight, as well as with other competitor's
products, it is safe to say that Consistent Software have earned
their name. WiseImage offers the most impressive, powerful and
consistent solution available in the market at present!
Pros
Cross-platform availability
AutoCAD compatibility
Excellent OCR recognition tools
Symbol recognition
Batch capabilities
OLE compliant
OCX module available
Cons
Non significant
Overall
If you have drawings and / or an AutoCAD system, you probably need
this product to fully utilize your existing and future paper
drawings. CU
www.csoft.no
|